Criteria |
4 (Exceptional) |
3 (Strong) |
2 (Developing) |
1 (Needs Improvement) |
Vision (25%)
Effectiveness in presenting a compelling and realistic vision of racial justice in Cobb County, with a nuanced Understanding of its complexities. |
Presents a highly compelling and realistic vision of a future with racial justice in Cobb County. Demonstrates a nuanced and sophisticated understanding of the complexities of racial justice, addressing potential challenges and offering innovative solutions. The vision is inspiring and actionable. |
Presents a compelling and realistic vision of a future with racial justice in Cobb County. Demonstrates a good understanding of the complexities of racial justice and offers thoughtful solutions. The vision is generally clear and achievable. |
Presents a vision of racial justice, but it may lack detail, realism, or a full understanding of the complexities involved. Solutions may be less developed or impactful. |
Struggles to present a coherent vision of racial justice. May oversimplify the issues or lack understanding of the challenges involved. The vision may be unrealistic or lack actionable steps. |
Personal Role and Action (20%)
Clarity and persuasiveness in articulating the student’s role and proposed actions, with specificity and long-term commitment. |
Articulates a clear, persuasive, and highly impactful personal role in achieving racial justice. Proposed actions are specific, actionable, and demonstrate a deep commitment to long-term engagement, both within and outside of school, and in future professional endeavors. |
Articulates a clear and persuasive personal role. Proposed actions are specific and actionable, demonstrating a commitment to long-term engagement and future contributions. |
Articulates a personal role, but it may lack clarity or persuasiveness. Proposed actions may be general or lack impact. Commitment to long-term engagement may be less evident. |
Struggles to articulate a personal role or propose meaningful actions. Demonstrates little commitment to long-term engagement. |
Understanding and Insight (20%)
Depth of understanding of historical and contemporary racism in Cobb County, including systemic barriers and strategies for dismantling them. |
Demonstrates a deep and insightful understanding of the historical and contemporary realities of racial injustice in Cobb County. Reflects a strong awareness of systemic barriers and a commitment to dismantling them. |
Demonstrates a good understanding of the historical and contemporary realities of racial injustice in Cobb County. Reflects an awareness of systemic barriers and a commitment to addressing them. |
Demonstrates some understanding of racial injustice, but may lack depth or nuance. Awareness of systemic barriers may be limited. |
Demonstrates a limited understanding of racial injustice and its impact. May oversimplify the issues or fail to recognize systemic barriers. |
Clarity and Organization (15%)
Logical flow, structure, and readability of the essay. |
Essay is exceptionally well-organized with a clear and logical flow of ideas. Writing is concise, engaging, and easy to understand. |
Essay is well-organized with a clear flow of ideas. Writing is generally concise and easy to understand. |
Essay shows some organization, but the flow of ideas may be inconsistent. Writing may be unclear or difficult to follow in places. |
Essay lacks clear organization and a logical flow of ideas. Writing is confusing or difficult to understand. |
Voice and Style (10%)
Authenticity, persuasiveness, and engagement of the student’s writing. |
Essay reflects the student’s authentic voice and perspective in a compelling and persuasive manner. Writing style is engaging and impactful. |
Essay reflects the student’s authentic voice and perspective. Writing style is generally engaging. |
Essay attempts to reflect the student’s voice, but it may not be fully developed or persuasive. |
Essay lacks a clear or authentic voice. Writing style is weak or ineffective. |
Mechanics and Presentation (10%)
Grammar, spelling, punctuation, and overall formatting. |
Essay is free of grammatical errors, spelling mistakes, and punctuation issues. Formatting is consistent and professional. |
Essay is generally free of grammatical errors, spelling mistakes, and punctuation issues. Formatting is mostly consistent. |
Essay contains some grammatical errors, spelling mistakes, or punctuation issues. Formatting may be inconsistent. |
Essay contains numerous grammatical errors, spelling mistakes, or punctuation issues. Formatting is inconsistent or unprofessional. |